Title: The architecture of attrition: Why do New Majority Learners disproportionately drop out of college? | Genio URL Source: https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college Published Time: Fri, 05 Jun 2026 14:03:40 GMT Markdown Content: # The architecture of attrition: Why do New Majority Learners disproportionately drop out of college? | Genio [Skip to main menu](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#main-menu)[Skip to footer](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#footer) * [Sign in](https://app.genio.co/account/sign-in) * [Get started for free](https://genio.co/pricing/get-genio-free) * [Activate a licence](https://app.genio.co/notes/activate)Activate a licence [](https://genio.co/)Genio logo - home * Products * Pricing * Resources * About Genio [Watch a demo](https://genio.co/watch-demo) [Genio Notes](https://genio.co/notes)Genio Notes ![Image 1: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Genio Notes The #1 note taking solution to boost knowledge, skills and confidence [The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass](https://genio.co/the-confident-notetakers-masterclass)The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass ![Image 2: The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_studying%20mh%20challenge.svg) The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass An on-demand online note taking course that helps you prepare for your studies [Genio Present](https://genio.co/present)Genio Present ![Image 3: Genio Present icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/present%20icon.png) Genio Present Our brand new tool to reduce presentation anxiety and build lasting communication skills Enter search term Search [Genio for institutions](https://genio.co/solutions/institutions)Genio for institutions ![Image 4: Implement Genio in your institution icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_higher%20ed.svg) Genio for institutions Learn why over 1,000 institutions around the world choose Genio [Genio for students](https://genio.co/solutions/students)Genio for students ![Image 5: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Genio for students Over 160,000 students are using Genio tools to unlock better learning [Recommend Genio](https://genio.co/resources/assessors-toolkit)Recommend Genio ![Image 6: Recommend Genio in needs assessments icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/recommend-glean-icon.svg) Recommend Genio Confidently demonstrate and recommend Genio's solutions [Why choose Genio](https://genio.co/solutions/why-choose-genio)Why choose Genio ![Image 7: Genio website favicon 300x300-1](https://genio.co/hubfs/Genio%20website%20favicon%20300x300-1.svg) Why choose Genio Explore all the reasons Genio is the #1 note taking solution to boost knowledge, skills and confidence [Packages for institutions](https://genio.co/pricing/institutions)Packages for institutions ![Image 8: roi-calculator-icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/roi-calculator-icon.svg) Packages for institutions Explore our packages and provide Genio Notes for students [Individual plans for students](https://genio.co/pricing/individuals)Individual plans for students ![Image 9: Individual plans for students icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_individual%20pricing.png) Individual plans for students Purchase a Genio Notes subscription for your studies or on behalf of someone else [Get Genio Notes free](https://genio.co/pricing/get-genio-free)Get Genio Notes free ![Image 10: icon_get genio free](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_get%20genio%20free.png) Get Genio Notes free Find out if you can get Genio Notes through government programs or your institution Enter search term Search [Institution Wide](https://genio.co/pricing/institution-wide)Institution Wide ![Image 11: Institution Wide icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/faculty-support-icon.svg) Institution Wide Drive student engagement and retention at your institution [ROI calculator](https://genio.co/resources/roi-calculator)ROI calculator ![Image 12: ROI calculator icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_balancing%20work.svg) ROI calculator See how much you could save by improving retention and persistence with Genio Notes [Request a demo account](https://genio.co/solutions/recommend-genio/demonstrator-account)Request a demo account ![Image 13: Request a demo account icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/tool-for-admins-icon.svg) Request a demo account [Activate a Genio Notes licence](https://app.genio.co/notes/activate)Activate a Genio Notes licence ![Image 14: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Activate a Genio Notes licence ###### Explore [Product and feature guides](https://genio.co/resources/product-and-feature-guides)Product and feature guides ![Image 15: Product and feature guides icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/video_guides-icon-01.svg) Product and feature guides [Learner support and retention](https://genio.co/resources/learner-support-and-retention)Learner support and retention ![Image 16: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Learner support and retention [Recommend Genio in needs assessments](https://genio.co/resources/assessors-toolkit)Recommend Genio in needs assessments ![Image 17: Recommend Genio in needs assessments icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/recommend-glean-icon.svg) Recommend Genio in needs assessments [Tips and advice for students](https://genio.co/resources/tips-and-advice-for-students)Tips and advice for students ![Image 18: Tips and advice for students icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_learning%20accessible.svg) Tips and advice for students [Implement Genio in your institution](https://genio.co/resources/implement-genio)Implement Genio in your institution ![Image 19: Implement Genio in your institution icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_higher%20ed.svg) Implement Genio in your institution [Accessibility and compliance](https://genio.co/resources/compliance-and-accessibility)Accessibility and compliance ![Image 20: Accessibility and compliance icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/it-icon.svg) Accessibility and compliance [Genio AI Hub](https://genio.co/ai-hub)Genio AI Hub ![Image 21: Genio AI Hub](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/about-us-icon.svg) Genio AI Hub [Support for STEM students](https://genio.co/notes/stem-study-support-tools)Support for STEM students ![Image 22: roi-calculator-icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/roi-calculator-icon.svg) Support for STEM students Enter search term Search ###### Browse [Events and webinars](https://genio.co/resources/events-and-webinars)Events and webinars ![Image 23: Events and webinars icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/events-icon.svg) Events and webinars [Case studies and user stories](https://genio.co/resources/case-studies-and-user-stories)Case studies and user stories ![Image 24: Case studies and user stories icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/case-studies-icon.svg) Case studies and user stories [Blog](https://genio.co/blog)Blog ![Image 25: Blog icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/blog-icon.svg) Blog [Research and insights](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights)Research and insights ![Image 26: Our Brand Story icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/guides-icon.svg) Research and insights [Help center](https://help.genio.co/)Help center ![Image 27: Help center icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/customer-support-icon.svg) Help center [Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders](https://genio.co/resources/learning-outcomes-leaders-podcast)Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders ![Image 28: Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders](https://genio.co/hubfs/mic.png) Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders [About us](https://genio.co/about)About us ![Image 29: About us icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/Genio%20website%20favicon%20300x300.svg) About us [Careers](https://genio.co/about/careers)Careers ![Image 30: Careers icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/careers-icon.svg) Careers [Research Accreditation Hub](https://genio.co/about/research-accreditation-hub)Research Accreditation Hub ![Image 31: Research Accreditation Hub icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_research%20accreditations.png) Research Accreditation Hub [Our Brand Story](https://genio.co/about/our-brand-story)Our Brand Story ![Image 32: Our Brand Story icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/guides-icon.svg) Our Brand Story [Life at Genio](https://genio.co/about/careers/life-at-genio)Life at Genio ![Image 33: Life at Genio icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_faculty%20staff.svg) Life at Genio [Contact us](https://genio.co/contact)Contact us ![Image 34: Contact us icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/contact-us-icon.svg) Contact us Enter search term Search [Home](https://genio.co/) * [Sign in](https://app.genio.co/account/sign-in) * [Get started for free](https://genio.co/pricing/get-genio-free) * [Activate a licence](https://app.genio.co/notes/activate) * [Watch a demo](https://genio.co/watch-demo) Enter search term Search * Products * [Genio Notes](https://genio.co/notes)Genio Notes![Image 35: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Genio Notes The #1 note taking solution to boost knowledge, skills and confidence [The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass](https://genio.co/the-confident-notetakers-masterclass)The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass![Image 36: The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_studying%20mh%20challenge.svg) The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass An on-demand online note taking course that helps you prepare for your studies [Genio Present](https://genio.co/present)Genio Present![Image 37: Genio Present icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/present%20icon.png) Genio Present Our brand new tool to reduce presentation anxiety and build lasting communication skills * [Genio for institutions](https://genio.co/solutions/institutions)Genio for institutions![Image 38: Implement Genio in your institution icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_higher%20ed.svg) Genio for institutions Learn why over 1,000 institutions around the world choose Genio [Genio for students](https://genio.co/solutions/students)Genio for students![Image 39: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Genio for students Over 160,000 students are using Genio tools to unlock better learning [Recommend Genio](https://genio.co/resources/assessors-toolkit)Recommend Genio![Image 40: Recommend Genio in needs assessments icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/recommend-glean-icon.svg) Recommend Genio Confidently demonstrate and recommend Genio's solutions [Why choose Genio](https://genio.co/solutions/why-choose-genio)Why choose Genio![Image 41: Genio website favicon 300x300-1](https://genio.co/hubfs/Genio%20website%20favicon%20300x300-1.svg) Why choose Genio Explore all the reasons Genio is the #1 note taking solution to boost knowledge, skills and confidence * Pricing * [Packages for institutions](https://genio.co/pricing/institutions)Packages for institutions![Image 42: roi-calculator-icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/roi-calculator-icon.svg) Packages for institutions Explore our packages and provide Genio Notes for students [Individual plans for students](https://genio.co/pricing/individuals)Individual plans for students ![Image 43: Individual plans for students icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_individual%20pricing.png) Individual plans for students Purchase a Genio Notes subscription for your studies or on behalf of someone else [Get Genio Notes free](https://genio.co/pricing/get-genio-free)Get Genio Notes free![Image 44: icon_get genio free](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_get%20genio%20free.png) Get Genio Notes free Find out if you can get Genio Notes through government programs or your institution * [Institution Wide](https://genio.co/pricing/institution-wide)Institution Wide![Image 45: Institution Wide icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/faculty-support-icon.svg) Institution Wide Drive student engagement and retention at your institution [ROI calculator](https://genio.co/resources/roi-calculator)ROI calculator![Image 46: ROI calculator icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_balancing%20work.svg) ROI calculator See how much you could save by improving retention and persistence with Genio Notes [Request a demo account](https://genio.co/solutions/recommend-genio/demonstrator-account)Request a demo account![Image 47: Request a demo account icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/tool-for-admins-icon.svg) Request a demo account [Activate a Genio Notes licence](https://app.genio.co/notes/activate)Activate a Genio Notes licence![Image 48: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Activate a Genio Notes licence * Resources * [Product and feature guides](https://genio.co/resources/product-and-feature-guides)Product and feature guides![Image 49: Product and feature guides icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/video_guides-icon-01.svg) Product and feature guides [Learner support and retention](https://genio.co/resources/learner-support-and-retention)Learner support and retention![Image 50: Learner support and retention icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/the_glean_study_tool_Icon.svg) Learner support and retention [Recommend Genio in needs assessments](https://genio.co/resources/assessors-toolkit)Recommend Genio in needs assessments![Image 51: Recommend Genio in needs assessments icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/recommend-glean-icon.svg) Recommend Genio in needs assessments [Tips and advice for students](https://genio.co/resources/tips-and-advice-for-students)Tips and advice for students![Image 52: Tips and advice for students icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_learning%20accessible.svg) Tips and advice for students [Implement Genio in your institution](https://genio.co/resources/implement-genio)Implement Genio in your institution![Image 53: Implement Genio in your institution icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_higher%20ed.svg) Implement Genio in your institution [Accessibility and compliance](https://genio.co/resources/compliance-and-accessibility)Accessibility and compliance ![Image 54: Accessibility and compliance icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/it-icon.svg) Accessibility and compliance [Genio AI Hub](https://genio.co/ai-hub)Genio AI Hub![Image 55: Genio AI Hub](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/about-us-icon.svg) Genio AI Hub [Support for STEM students](https://genio.co/notes/stem-study-support-tools)Support for STEM students![Image 56: roi-calculator-icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/roi-calculator-icon.svg) Support for STEM students * [Events and webinars](https://genio.co/resources/events-and-webinars)Events and webinars![Image 57: Events and webinars icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/events-icon.svg) Events and webinars [Case studies and user stories](https://genio.co/resources/case-studies-and-user-stories)Case studies and user stories![Image 58: Case studies and user stories icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/case-studies-icon.svg) Case studies and user stories [Blog](https://genio.co/blog)Blog![Image 59: Blog icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/blog-icon.svg) Blog [Research and insights](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights)Research and insights![Image 60: Our Brand Story icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/guides-icon.svg) Research and insights [Help center](https://help.genio.co/)Help center![Image 61: Help center icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/customer-support-icon.svg) Help center [Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders](https://genio.co/resources/learning-outcomes-leaders-podcast)Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders![Image 62: Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders](https://genio.co/hubfs/mic.png) Genio Podcast: Learning Outcomes Leaders * About Genio * [About us](https://genio.co/about)About us![Image 63: About us icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/Genio%20website%20favicon%20300x300.svg) About us [Careers](https://genio.co/about/careers)Careers![Image 64: Careers icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/careers-icon.svg) Careers [Research Accreditation Hub](https://genio.co/about/research-accreditation-hub)Research Accreditation Hub![Image 65: Research Accreditation Hub icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/icon_research%20accreditations.png) Research Accreditation Hub [Our Brand Story](https://genio.co/about/our-brand-story)Our Brand Story![Image 66: Our Brand Story icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/guides-icon.svg) Our Brand Story [Life at Genio](https://genio.co/about/careers/life-at-genio)Life at Genio![Image 67: Life at Genio icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/megamenu%20icon_faculty%20staff.svg) Life at Genio [Contact us](https://genio.co/contact)Contact us![Image 68: Contact us icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/menu-icons/contact-us-icon.svg) Contact us * [Watch a demo](https://genio.co/watch-demo) [](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college) # The architecture of attrition: Why do New Majority Learners disproportionately drop out of college? This in-depth literature review explores how New Majority Learners face unique challenges in college retention, driven by external pressures and unmet needs, rather than academic performance alone. #### Key takeaways: * 21% of college students with a GPA between 2.5 and 3.0 drop out of higher education, despite their secure academic performance * Non-academic, external pressures are actively pulling capable students out of the academic pipeline 66% of undergraduate college students with an underlying learning disability choose not to inform their college of their status * Research reveals a distinct "dose-response" relationship between unmet basic needs and college attrition indicators * Retention should not be viewed exclusively as a question of student resilience, but as a measure of institutional adaptability [](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college) #### Traditional, full-time students entering college immediately after high school are no longer the demographic at the heart of the US higher education system (Cahalan et al., 2024). Instead, New Majority Learners (NMLs) encompassing first-generation, low-income, mature, part-time, and working students, now comprise the majority of undergraduates (Cahalan et al., 2024; Cataldi et al., 2018). Yet, institutional retention frameworks remain anchored in legacy models that treat college dropouts as a reflection of individual academic inadequacy (Tight, 2020). By examining operational friction, generational disparities, the acute penalties of time poverty, and the cumulative impact of unmet essential needs, this literature review highlights why New Majority Learners (NMLs) remain at a higher risk of dropout than their peers (Kim, 2025). To combat this, US colleges must move away from passively tracking student failure and instead become friction architects within supportive institutional ecosystems (Lawrence et al., 2019; Sanborn et al., 2024; Todd, 2023). This shift involves using technology to automate unproductive friction (like logistical noise and note-taking) while preserving productive friction (the mental effort required for deep encoding and retrieval) to ensure knowledge retention (Chen et al., 2025; Skulmowski, 2023). [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## Are low grades alone to blame for higher drop out rates? ##### Historically, US higher education institutions have viewed student attrition through a remedial lens, assuming that college dropouts are primarily driven by academic insufficiency or failing grades (Tight, 2020). While poor grades can certainly be a factor in choosing to leave higher education, structural factors still prevail in underpinning the likelihood of a student choosing to drop out (Bäulke et al., 2022). A recent study by the National Bureau of Economic Research found that first-generation students who encounter negative grade events in their first year of higher education have a 40% likelihood of dropping out - 5% higher than observationally identical continuing generation students who face the same setback (NBER, 2025). Rather than dropping out, continuing-generation students are instead more likely to simply switch majors (NBER, 2025). However, academic underperformance alone is insufficient to explain attrition patterns, as large numbers of academically stable students also exit higher education prematurely. ![Image 69: Illustration of a laptop and headphones](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/Genio%20illustrations_notes.png?width=800&height=800&name=Genio%20illustrations_notes.png) ![Image 70: Illustration of a notepad, mobile phone and a magnifying glass](https://genio.co/hubfs/ILL_NOTES%20capture%20class%20attention.png) First year students with a GPA below 2.0 have a 75% departure rate, with this rate falling to 21% once a GPA between 2.5 and 3.0 has been achieved (Westrick et al., 2023). A GPA within the 2.5 to 3.0 range indicates that students are academically secure, possessing the intellectual aptitude to satisfy institutional benchmarks and pass their courses (Westrick et al., 2023). Yet, over 1 in 5 of students within this GPA range continue on their path to leaving higher education. Their decision to drop out therefore cannot be attributed to a deficit in learning capability or a failure to comprehend course material. Instead, this academic stability demonstrates that non-academic, external pressures are actively pulling capable students out of the academic pipeline (Bean & Metzner, 1985; Sanborn et al., 2024). Therefore, when institutions focus their retention efforts exclusively on remedial academic tutoring or grade-monitoring systems, they misdiagnose the root cause of attrition (Tight, 2020). For New Majority Learners, a passing grade is a necessary, but ultimately insufficient condition for persistence. Instead, their survival depends upon them not only succeeding academically, but also navigating a complex mix of structural hurdles that operate entirely outside the classroom walls (Bean & Metzner, 1985; Sanborn et al., 2024) [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## How has the demographic landscape changed? ##### The table below highlights the structural vulnerabilities characterising the modern undergraduate profile across US institutions: | Category of risk | Demographic attribute | Share of US student body (NCES, 2025) | Key retention / persistence metric | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | The time-poor learner | | | Working while enrolled | 69.3% | Students who work while enrolled are approximately **20% less likely to complete their degrees** than similar peers who don't work. Ecton et al., 2023 | | | Part-time enrollment | 39.6% | **46.8% of part-time freshmen** fail to persist to their second fall term. National Student Clearinghouse, 2025 | | | Student parents | 19.2% | **61% of student fathers** drop out without a degree, and **48% of student mothers**. Reichlin Cruse et al., 2022 | | The underprepared learner | | | Adult learners (age 22+) | 43.8% | **More than half** of all adult learners stop out after their first year. Munip, 2024 | | | First-generation students | 54% | Only **24% of first-generation students** graduate, compared to **59%** of their continuing-generation peers. First Gen Forward, 2026 | | Individual / systemic barriers | | | Racial/ethnic minorities | 33.5% | Fall retention rates for Black students (**58.5%**) and Hispanic students (**65.4%**) lag behind the national average of 69.5%. National Student Clearinghouse, 2025 | | | Neurodivergent students | 16.5% | Six-year graduation rate for students with any documented disability is **49.5%**, vs **68%** for peers without disabilities. NCES, 2024 | [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## How do time and flexibility factor into retention? ##### Traditional higher education architecture assumes that learning occurs in a dedicated, singular space, operating on the premise that the traditional student is unencumbered by domestic or financial responsibilities (Todd, 2023). For a New Majority Learner balancing a 30-hour work week or childcare, the rigid timelines of standard campuses act as an active exclusion mechanism, driving the attrition gaps between themselves and their full-time traditional peers (Sallee et al 2024). This generates an acute crisis of ‘time poverty’ for New Majority Learners (Wladis, Hachey, & Conway, 2018). ![Image 71: Illustration of a clock, a computer monitor, a notebook, a pencil and a fidget toy](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/ILL_adhd.png?width=300&height=387&name=ILL_adhd.png) ![Image 72: Illustration of seedlings, a mobile phone, a wall calendar and a clock](https://genio.co/hubfs/ILL_seedlings%20cultivate%20organised%20calendar%20time%20clock%20plan.png) When balancing the competing demands of employment, caregiving, and academics, student-parents and working students are left with virtually zero margin for error (Sallee, Lewis, & Kieffer, 2024). For example, students actively working while enrolled face immense time pressures, often falling short of institutional expectations for independent study hours simply because they lack the necessary time and financial resources (Wright et al., 2024). In this context, typical university practices, such as mandatory in-person attendance or last-minute timetable changes, create severe logistical conflicts that disproportionately penalize these learners (Moreau & Kerner, 2012; Todd, 2023; Wright et al., 2024). Because the time constraints of a traditional university force a strict separation between a student's academic life and their personal responsibilities, New Majority Learners are frequently forced to choose between their education and their families or livelihoods (Holmes & Nikiforidou, 2023; Sallee et al., 2024). This operational friction drives a gap in degree completion (Bean & Metzner, 1985). [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## How do assumptions negatively impact learners with additional needs? ##### The theoretical architecture of the traditional university is built upon a flawed baseline that assumes a completely neurotypical and able-bodied student identity (Nieminen, 2023; Brown et al, 2022; Vallee, 2017). Just as legacy schedules alienate the time-poor worker, traditional classroom environments systematically isolate neurodivergent learners who face pronounced academic hurdles within rigid, one-size-fits-all lecture formats (Hamblet, 2015; Gabi & Sharpe, 2019). ![Image 73: Illustration of a plant, a laptop, a cube and paper with braille](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/ILL_blind.png?width=1191&height=1084&name=ILL_blind.png) ![Image 74: Illustration of a laptop, a mobile phone, and a drinks can](https://genio.co/hubfs/ILL_REMOTE%20student%20laptop%20video%20call%20snacks.png) Traditional retention models assume that vulnerable students will simply self-advocate and utilize campus support systems. Yet, the reality of navigating complex institutional bureaucracy introduces a secondary layer of administrative friction (Swirsky et al., 2024). 66% of undergraduate college students with an underlying learning disability choose not to inform their college of their status (Shifrer et al., 2025). Furthermore, even when students attempt to seek help, institutional bottlenecks create an accommodation deficit, with an additional 11% informing their institution of their needs but ultimately receiving zero official programming or support (Shifrer et al., 2025). This leaves less than a quarter of neurodivergent students, who navigate the reporting pipeline, to receive official campus accommodations. Consequently, rather than fighting an institutional baseline, the marginal neurodivergent learner quietly exits the pipeline, driven out by the cumulative toll of an inflexible environment (Bean & Metzner, 1985; Vallee, 2017). [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## Why are New Majority Learners more susceptible to the hidden curriculum? ##### The demographic evolution of higher education has brought first-generation college students to the forefront of the student body, yet institutional design continues to assume a baseline of inherited collegiate literacy (Cataldi et al., 2018; Farris, 2022). First-generation students represent a significant subgroup within the broader population of New Majority Learners, whose experiences often intersect with other non-traditional student identities and structural barriers. As such, the challenges faced by first-generation learners reflect wider institutional tensions surrounding equity, access, and student support within contemporary higher education (Farris, 2022; López et al., 2023). ![Image 75: Illustration of a wall calendar, a mobile phone with a notification icon, a photo frame, and a watch](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/ILL_CALENDAR%20event%20organise%20schedule%20alarm%20holiday.png?width=429&height=403&name=ILL_CALENDAR%20event%20organise%20schedule%20alarm%20holiday.png) ![Image 76: Illustration of a lamp, a notebook, and a noticeboard](https://genio.co/hubfs/BLOG_improve%20sutdy%20skills%20HERO.png) Despite 54% of all undergraduate students identifying as first-generation, only 24% successfully graduate, compared to 59% of their continuing-generation peers (First Gen Forward, 2026). Closing this gap would produce an estimated 4.4 million additional graduates and a $700 billion net benefit to the U.S. economy (First Gen Forward, 2026). This illustrates the protective power of generational social capital (Cataldi et al., 2018; Ricks & Warren, 2021). Students whose parents have earned a bachelor's degree possess an invisible framework of support - familial knowledge that is passed down on factors like how to navigate financial aid, access academic advising, utilize office hours, and overcome administrative roadblocks (Cataldi et al., 2018; Farris, 2022). Conversely, first-generation New Majority Learners often confront the ‘hidden curriculum’ of higher education entirely in isolation (Babineau, 2018.; Farris, 2022). When academic or administrative friction arises, the lack of a familiar sounding board or experiential guidance amplifies feelings of institutional alienation (Ricks & Warren, 2021). The fact that first-generation learners are more than twice as unlikely to graduate as their continuing-generation peers is not a reflection of a lower commitment to education; rather, it represents the penalty of navigating a complex, bureaucratic system without an inherited roadmap (Babineau, 2018; Farris, 2022). > **_"Students facing four unmet essential needs exhibit 82% greater odds (an adjusted odds ratio of 1.82) of experiencing an attrition indicator compared to their peers with zero unmet needs."_** > > > (Sanborn et al., 2024) [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## How do unmet needs add to the cognitive load? ##### While traditional retention models emphasize psychological factors like motivation or institutional integration (Tinto, 1975), recent public health approaches claim that retention is deeply tied to a student's basic physical security (Sanborn et al., 2024). New Majority Learners are disproportionately exposed to material instability, including housing insecurity, food scarcity, lack of reliable transportation, and inadequate mental health support (Broton & Goldrick-Rab, 2018; Sanborn et al., 2024). Rather than acting as isolated incidents, these compounding vulnerabilities exert a cumulative attrition load onto the student (Sanborn et al., 2024). ![Image 77: Illustration of a gym bar bench and a barbell with books as weights](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/ILL-note%20taking%20is%20a%20skill-1.png?width=350&height=363&name=ILL-note%20taking%20is%20a%20skill-1.png) ![Image 78: Illustration of of a laptop](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/live%20captions%20illustration.png?width=350&height=350&name=live%20captions%20illustration.png) Research reveals a distinct "dose-response" relationship between unmet basic needs and college attrition indicators. As in epidemiology where a higher dose of a pathogen increases the severity of an illness, each additional unmet essential need increases the probability of a student dropping out (Sanborn et al., 2024). This is exacerbated by extreme wealth disparities. Recent research focused on US medical students found that 17.1% of first-generation students came from households in the lowest national income quintile (Kamran et al., 2025). Kamran et al (2025)’s study continued to demonstrate the impact of familial wealth on graduation, finding that students in the highest parental income group had a higher probability of graduation compared to students with parents in the lowest income group. When a student is simultaneously forced to navigate food insecurity, housing instability, and childcare deficits, their cognitive bandwidth is completely consumed by immediate survival (Sanborn et al., 2024; Scharp et al., 2020). [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## How should institutions combat increased attrition? ##### The evidence presented throughout this review demonstrates that when it comes to the New Majority Learner, attrition cannot be understood through the lens of academic performance alone. While traditional frameworks continue to position dropouts as the outcome of individual academic deficiency, the experiences of New Majority Learners reveal a far more complex reality shaped by structural friction, institutional rigidity, and cumulative external pressures (Tight, 2020, Sallee et al., 2024; Sanborn et al., 2024). These students are disproportionately exposed to systems designed around outdated assumptions of what a ‘traditional’ student looks like (Todd, 2023, Cahalan et al., 2024). Consequently, as higher education demographics continue to evolve, institutions that fail to adapt their operational architecture are at risk of reproducing attrition (Chen et al., 2020). ![Image 79: Illustration of a notebook, a magic cube and a noticeboard](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/Genio%20Assets/Genio%20illustrations_underprepared.png?width=800&height=800&name=Genio%20illustrations_underprepared.png) ![Image 80: Illustration of a trophy, a contract, a medal, and a paper plane](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/Glean_April2022/Image/ILL_SUCCESS_pass_stamp_trophy_paper_plane_medal_17c03cb18d.png?width=571&height=443&name=ILL_SUCCESS_pass_stamp_trophy_paper_plane_medal_17c03cb18d.png) This reframes the role of higher education institutions. Rather than acting solely as evaluators of academic performance, colleges and universities must increasingly function as friction architects of accessible learning ecosystems capable of reducing student’s unnecessary operational burden (Lawrence et al., 2019; Sanborn et al., 2024). Retention, therefore, should not be viewed exclusively as a question of student resilience, but as a measure of institutional adaptability. As the New Majority Learner becomes the defining profile of modern higher education, the institutions most capable of improving retention outcomes will likely be those that move beyond reactive support models and instead proactively redesign the learning experience around flexibility, accessibility, and cognitive sustainability (Todd, 2023, Sallee, et al., 2024). The future of student success may therefore depend less on identifying which students are ‘at risk’, and more on examining which institutional systems continue to place unnecessary risk upon them. [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ![Image 81: NML lecture illustration 2 (1)](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/NML%20lecture%20illustration%202%20(1).png?width=200&height=200&name=NML%20lecture%20illustration%202%20(1).png) ## How to improve outcomes for the New Majority Learner Learn how non-traditional students are now the majority and what that means for student success. [Read the New Majority Learner Report 2026](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/new-majority-learner-report-2026) [Back to top](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college#top-of-page) ## Bibliography * Babineau, K. (n.d.). Closing the Gap: An Overview of the Literature on College Persistence and Underrepresented Populations. Cowen Institute * Bäulke, L., Grunschel, C., & Dresel, M. (2022). [Student dropout at university: A phase-oriented model of a longitudinal decision process.](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-021-00794-x)Higher Education, 84(4), 649–667. * Bean, J. P., & Metzner, B. S. (1985). [A conceptual model of nontraditional undergraduate student attrition.](https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543055004485) Review of Educational Research, 55(4), 485–540. * Broton, K. M., & Goldrick-Rab, S. (2018). [Going without: An introduction to food and housing insecurity among college students](https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X17751352). Educational Researcher, 47(2), 121–133. * Brown, N., Leigh, J., & Baker, S. (2022). [Exploring experiences of ableism in academia: a constructivist inquiry](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-021-00739-y). Higher Education, 83(6), 1225–1239. * Cahalan, M. W., Perna, L. W., Addison, M., Murray, C., & Patel, P. R. (2024). Indicators of Higher Education Equity in the United States: 2024 Historical Trend Report. The Pell Institute for the Study of Opportunity in Higher Education & Alliance for Higher Education and Democracy of the University of Pennsylvania (PennAHEAD). * Cataldi, E. F., Bennett, C. T., & Chen, X. (2018). First-Generation Students: College Access, Persistence, and Postbachelor’s Outcomes (NCES 2018-421). U.S. Department of Education. Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics. * Chen, J., Ziskin, M. B., & Torres, V. (2020). An Analysis of Factors Affecting Dropout Risks of Nontraditional Students: Evidence from U.S. 4-Year Commuter Institutions. International Journal of Educational Reform, 29(1), 38-59 * Chen, X., Ruan, K., Ju, K. P., Yap, N., & Wang, X. (2025). [More AI assistance reduces cognitive engagement: Examining the AI assistance dilemma in AI-supported note-taking](https://doi.org/10.1145/3757632). Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, 9(CSCW2), Article 451.[](https://doi.org/10.1145/3757632) * Ecton, W. G., Heinrich, C. J., & Carruthers, C. K. (2023). [Earning to learn: Working while enrolled in Tennessee colleges and universities](https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584221140405). AERA Open, 9(1), 1–16. * Farris, M. (2022). Decoding the hidden curriculum: Cultivating capital among first-generation college students. Journal of College Student Development, 63(3), 291–306. * FirstGen Forward. (2026). National Data Fact Sheets: Structural Persistence, Economic Benefits, and Attrition Among First-Generation Undergraduates. Center for First-Generation Student Success. * Gabi, J., & Sharpe, S. (2019). Understand the myriad factors affecting student retention: Dyslexia and hidden neurodivergence in higher education. Journal of Inclusive Practice in Further and Higher Education, 11(1), 45–59. * Genio. (2026). The Impact of AI on Note-Taking in Higher Education: Shifting to Friction Architecture and Protecting the New Majority Learner. Genio Resources Hub. * Hamblet, E. C. (2015). From high school to college: Transition success for students with disabilities. Harvard Educational Review, 85(2), 220–238. * Holmes, S., & Nikiforidou, Z. (2023). ["They don't realise how hard it is": Investigating the lived experiences of higher education students with parental responsibilities during the Covid‐19 pandemic"](https://doi.org/10.1111/hequ.12411). Higher Education Quarterly, 77(4), 638–654. * Kamran SC, Pompa IR, Nguyen HB, et al. First-Generation and Low-Income Students in the National Medical Student Body. JAMA Netw Open. 2025;8(5):e259769. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.9769 * Kim, J. (2025). What Do They Suffer? An Examination of Personal, Program, and Environmental Factors Impacting Nontraditional Undergraduate Students’ Dropout. Journal of College Student Retention: Research, Theory & Practice, 27(3), 744-762. * Lawrence, J., Brown, A., Redmond, P., & Basson, M. (2019). Engaging the disengaged: Exploring the use of course-specific learning analytics and nudging to enhance online student engagement. Student Success, 10(2), 47-58 * López, María & Santelices, Verónica & Taveras, Carmen. (2023). Academic performance and adjustment of first-generation students to higher education: A systematic review. Cogent Education. 10. 10.1080/2331186X.2023.2209484. * Moreau, M. P., & Kerner, C. (2012). [School‐childcare conflicts: Working student‐parents in higher education](https://doi.org/10.1080/0309877X.2011.596510). Journal of Further and Higher Education, 36(2), 215–233. * Munip, A. (2024). The First-Year Horizon: Predicting and Preventing Stop-Out Behaviors Among Adult Undergraduate Learners. Academic Press. * National Bureau of Economic Research [NBER]. (2025). [Understanding Gaps in College Outcomes by First-Generation Status (Working Paper No. w34129)](https://www.nber.org/papers/w34129). NBER. * National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (2024). Undergraduates with Disabilities: Enrollment, Characteristics, and Performance Outcomes. U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences. * National Center for Education Statistics [NCES]. (2025). Report on the Condition of Education 2025 U.S. Department of Education, Washington, DC: National Center for Education Statistics. * National Student Clearinghouse Research Center. (2025). Persistence and Retention Report: Fall 2024 Cohort Tracking. National Student Clearinghouse. * Nieminen, J. H. (2023). [Unveiling ableism and disablism in assessment: A critical analysis of disabled students’ experiences of assessment and assessment accommodations](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10734-022-00857-1). Higher Education, 85(3), 613–636. * Redford, J., & Hoyer, K. M. (2017). First-Generation College Students: Demographic Characteristics and Postsecondary Enrollment (NCES 2018-009). National Center for Education Statistics. * Reichlin Cruse, L., Contreras-Mendez, S., & Gault, B. (2022). The Landscape of Student Parents in US Higher Education: Enrollment, Attrition, and Equity. Institute for Women's Policy Research. * Ricks, J., & Warren, J. (2021). Generational social capital as an insulation factor against administrative friction. Journal of Diversity in Higher Education, 14(4), 512–526. * Sallee, M., Lewis, D., & Kieffer, S. (2024). Collapsing borders: How online education shapes student-mothers' experiences in higher education. Access: Critical Explorations of Equity in Higher Education, 12(1), 89–105. * Sanborn, J., Jones, H. E., Manze, M., Twiste, T., & Freudenberg, N. (2024). [The cumulative impact of unmet essential needs on indicators of attrition: Findings from a public university population-based sample of students in the Bronx, NY](https://doi.org/10.1007/s11524-024-00872-w). Journal of Urban Health, 101(5), 764–774. * Scharp, K. M., Thomas, L., & Canary, H. (2020). Overwhelmed by survival: Chronic stress, food insecurity, and cognitive load among non-traditional students. Communication Education, 69(3), 305–322. * Shifrer, D., & Mackin Freeman, A. (2025). College outcomes for young adults with and without learning disabilities and ADHD: Formal-disability-programming and informal-disability-supports. Journal of Postsecondary Education and Disability, 38(1), 45–62. * Shifrer, D., Springer, R., Ellefritz, H. S., & Tilbrook, N. (2025). [College outcomes for young adults with and without learning disabilities and ADHD: Formal-disability-programming and informal-disability-supports](https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2025.2463857). The Journal of Higher Education. Advance online publication. * Skulmowski, A. (2023). [Cognitive externalization in digital learning: A cognitive load perspective](https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-023-09818-1). Educational Psychology Review, 35, 101. * Swirsky, E., Wright, T., & Zhao, J. (2024). Campus Climate Surveys: Disability Resource Center Utilization and Accessibility Gaps. American Council on Education. * Tight, M. (2020). [Student retention and drop-out in higher education. Studies in Higher Education](https://doi.org/10.1080/03075079.2019.1650197), 45(11), 2277–2288. * Tinto, V. (1975). [Dropout from higher education: A theoretical synthesis of recent research](https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543045001089). Review of Educational Research, 45(1), 89–125. * Todd, R. (2023). Neoliberal universities and time poverty: The structural exclusion of non-traditional student profiles. Educational Policy Analysis, 31(4), 402–421. * Vallee, J. (2017). Dismantling the neurotypical baseline: Re-envisioning student engagement through an ableism-critical lens. Radical Pedagogy, 14(2), 88–109. * Westrick, P. A., Marini, J. P., Young, L., Ng, H., & Shaw, E. J. (2023). The consequences of a low first-year grade point average on later college outcomes. College Board. * Wladis, C., Hachey, A. C., & Conway, K. (2018). [No time for college? An assessment of time poverty among student parents](https://doi.org/10.1080/00221546.2018.1442983). The Journal of Higher Education, 89(6), 907–933. * Wooclap. (2025). How many people drop out of college: National statistical analysis and financial pressure vectors. Wooclap Insights. * Wright, T., Peterson, K., & Lee, S. (2024). The independent study myth: How working student hours fail to meet institutional assumptions. Journal of Higher Education Work and Learning, 28(2), 143–158. [Genio logo - home](https://genio.co/) * Products * [Genio Notes](https://genio.co/notes) * [The Confident Notetaker's Masterclass](https://genio.co/the-confident-notetakers-masterclass) * [Genio Present](https://genio.co/present) * Pricing and plans * [For institutions](https://genio.co/pricing/institutions) * [Institution Wide package](https://genio.co/pricing/institution-wide) * [Individual user quote](https://cc.genio.co/genio-individual-user-quote-request) * [ROI calculator](https://genio.co/resources/roi-calculator) * [For individuals](https://genio.co/pricing/individuals) * [Get Genio Notes for free](https://genio.co/pricing/get-genio-free) * Why choose Genio * [Genio for institutions](https://genio.co/solutions/institutions) * [Genio for students](https://genio.co/solutions/students) * [Recommend Genio](https://genio.co/resources/assessors-toolkit) * Resources * [Blog](https://genio.co/blog) * [Events and webinars](https://genio.co/resources/events-and-webinars) * [Case studies and user stories](https://genio.co/resources/case-studies-and-user-stories) * [Product and feature guides](https://genio.co/resources/product-and-feature-guides) * [Research and insights](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights) * [Sign in](https://app.genio.co/account/sign-in) * About us * [About us](https://genio.co/about) * [Careers](https://genio.co/about/careers) * [Our Brand Story](https://genio.co/about/our-brand-story) * [Our history](https://genio.co/about/our-history) * [Research Accreditation Hub](https://genio.co/about/research-accreditation-hub) * [Media Kit](https://genio.co/about/media-kit) * Contact and support * [Get in touch](https://genio.co/contact) * [Help centre](https://help.genio.co/)Opens in a new tab * [Device compatibility](https://genio.co/specification) * [Service status](https://status.genio.co/)Opens in a new tab * [Visit us on our social](https://www.facebook.com/GenioLearn) * [Visit us on our social](https://www.instagram.com/geniolearn) * [Visit us on our social](https://uk.linkedin.com/company/geniolearn) * [Visit us on our social](https://www.youtube.com/@geniotools) * [Visit us on our social](https://www.tiktok.com/@geniolearn) * [![Image 82: Icon](https://genio.co/hs-fs/hubfs/website/vectors/Google_Play_Store_badge_EN.png?width=120&name=Google_Play_Store_badge_EN.png)Download app](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=co.genio.notes) * [![Image 83: Icon](https://genio.co/hubfs/website/vectors/Download_on_the_App_Store_Badge_US-UK_RGB_blk_092917.svg)Download app](https://apps.apple.com/gb/app/genio-notes/id6758772863) * [Privacy Notice](https://genio.co/privacy-notice) * [Service Agreement](https://genio.co/service-agreement) * [Accessibility Statement](https://genio.co/accessibility-statement) * [Data Security](https://genio.co/security) * [Third Party Licenses](https://genio.co/third-party-code-licenses) * [Cookie Preferences](https://genio.co/cookies) [](https://genio.co/resources/research-and-insights/the-architecture-of-attrition-why-do-new-majority-learners-disproportionately-drop-out-of-college)